YOU TUBE AND VSOCIAL CREATING NEW PARADIGM
More Homemade Music Videos Bubble on YouTube
User-generated music videos continue to pop up on destinations like YouTube and Google, raising the ire of the recording industry and publishers. Amateur performers often use masters as the backdrop to recorded lip-syncing sessions, and rightholders are alleging that the resulting videos are being disseminated without the proper rights clearances. The videos can certainly reach a substantial audience. The latest example features a young woman singing alongside "Maneater" by Hall & Oates – a submission that quickly became one of YouTube's most viewed pieces with over 200,000 views over a two day period. Meanwhile, users have reportedly begun receiving takedown letters for their amateur dalliances, part of a growing face-off.
Some believe the homemade pieces serve a promotional purpose, encouraging the purchase of the music depicted in the video. Perhaps bolstering this argument, two of the three Google Ads displayed next to the YouTube "Maneater" video are for ringtone services. Others might argue that user-generated pieces compete with, and degrade the sale of, legitimate music videos that are available for purchase through services like iTunes. Whether YouTube videos cannibalize the market for the original videos is a debatable point, especially considering the homemade nature and unique artistic qualities of the user-generated content. Often, YouTube videos do not even employ any component of the original videos. What's more, amateur videos might arguably be "non-commercial" in nature, though destinations like YouTube monetize third-party content with advertisements. Of course, rights holders may have a stronger case for infringement when it comes to the use of masters and underlying songs without permission.
